In brief this is the picture of how he has portrayed of himself (note he did not say this to everyone, or all at once - he was too clever for that and it's what I have pieced together):
- He was David Cameron's personal advisor and representative
- He reported only and personally to David Cameron and the Chief Whip
- Only the Chief Whip and his "good friend" William Hague knew his identity online
- He was on the same level with Andy Coulson, was offered his job, but refused it
- He previously worked for the Canadian PM and was personally head-hunted to work for ours
- Somehow, however, he also fitted in working for the Archbishop of Canterbury in comms
- He had read theology, trained as a priest, worked as a policeman briefly in Ontario, then as a pilot, before going into politics/ communications. He suffers from MS.
Just to be clear, the "Lord" title has always been a joke - he and a couple of others took the title at the time of one of the Honours Lists. Before that he was just "The_Credo". I don't think anyone ever took the Lord title to be a real thing.
Credo resigned his job for David Cameron in May, but is currently on gardening leave. This was because of a personal falling out, even though the Prime Minister has apparently called him and begged him to return to his job. It coincides with the diagnosis of a brain tumour (more on this later).
Credo's "offline" name is Mike Paterson. He has always taken pains to protect his identity, because he is so "high level". I did hear him give this name, however, in my presence to officers of the Essex Constabulary in May 2011.
Emperor's New Clothes
I had huge doubts Credo could possibly be who he said he was quite early on. Many of us did; how could anyone be tweeting as much as he did in a job so high level, and be so indiscreet about government goings on. However, we met and he seemed genuine. Very likeable in fact.
Moreover I met him the presence of a BBC chap (who is real) and two people who work in the Commons (who are also real). I saw him talking online to people like Sally Bercow (I was in Hampshire hotel lobby with him when her name flashed up on his mobile). I'd been to drinks with him and the infamous undercover blogger and real life journalist Fleet Street Fox. More recently he's been talking openly to Louise Mensch MP: people see this, they see his profile bio, and don't think any thing more than "he must be real".
Indeed, the Huffington Post ran an interview (click on link) with "Credo" on 3 August 2011 as one of top four "Tories who tweet anonymously". In this he speaks with extreme self-assurance about his top position. The journalists involved clearly did not bother to delve too much further into his actual identity.
Remember the Hans Christian Andersen Story? Everyone in the crowd looks on at the Emperor who is not wearing anything. Because everyone thinks everyone else can see the lovely clothes, not a soul says a thing. Credo didn't ever turn up in nice clothes though - he wore the same threadbare ill-fitting jacket every time I saw him, coming from "work" or from home, clutching a dirty worn out BBC bag. But none of us was the little boy in the crowd who shouted out "he's naked!"
Abuse of Friendship
Credo weaseled his way into my group of friends. He and his girlfriend spent the entire summer staying with various of them, moving from house to house, apparently because his house in Sussex had sold and a new purchase had fallen through. The longest was 8 weeks with a lovely woman, from whom he "borrowed" money and didn't pay a penny in food contributions, towards utilities or the huge phone bill he ran up. He also borrowed cash from another friend on Twitter. It was a standing joke that Credo would come along to drinks and forget his wallet. He has asked all of us to put him up at one time another; more recently there have been requests for money.
When he was "diagnosed" with cancer - a malignant brain tumour - we were all extremely concerned. He announced it online: his follower count shot up. Offers of support and help poured in. He told us his wife, from whom he was estranged, had suddenly committed suicide in Sydney just before their divorce was finalised. She was a medical doctor and knew which pills to take. As a result of the divorce however, all his accounts were frozen. The latest was that he was expecting a cheque for hundreds of thousands of pounds from the estate - but somehow it never arrived. Credo's cancer fortunately disappeared amazingly rapidly; when I saw him I couldn't believe how well he looked. It was almost as if he had never had it...
I'd had a former Lib Dem friend who had constantly doubted Credo could be who he said he was. He had worked at the House of Commons and rationally set out his doubts. I simply refused to believe it. I liked Mike and yes some of these things were a bit odd. When he claimed to have been instrumental in bringing Andy Coulson down and presented him with damning evidence - well it was brushed off as Credo blowing his own trumpet. The epic 48 hour drive he made to Scotland at Christmas just didn't seem real; the time he was in Amsterdam and crossing areas on foot faster than a gazelle (at around 18 stone, Mike is NO gazelle) didn't quite add up. The sheer amount of drama and chaos going on in one person's life - from his mother having a stroke, then breast cancer, then a heart-by pass... through to the dead wife. It just didn't seem plausible. But my friends knew him and "proper" people were talking to him online.
Rumbled
Then he came up to my home in Suffolk last week. He was showing off about having picked up "1000 followers during the riots". It seemed to all be going to his head. I'd unfortunately seen this before (click on link: a fake QC, much less high profile). Mike offered to invest £250,000 in my business project. He failed to recognise a very well known Henry Mee portrait at a friend's house - its twin is hanging at Portcullis House - and seemed embarrassed. He failed to answer an email about the investment. He claimed his phone had been switched off for 24 hours (given the PM calls him night and day this seemed unlikely). He made a big show of his having poured wine over his laptop - a reason he hadn't answered my email perhaps? I'm not Miss Marple, but alarm bells were ringing and this made me want to talk to people.
So those of us who knew him started talking to one another. It's not easy if you're wrong to be going out there and doubting every thing about a friend, to your mutual friends. Through a contact, David Cameron's Deputy Chief of Staff confirmed no one had knowledge of a Michael Paterson who had ever worked for the Prime Minister. I got in touch with the people I'd seen him with at pubs in Whitehall: no one had actually checked him out. When he boasted he'd had "top level background checks" I asked the person who apparently had carried them out. He hadn't.
I also spoke to @markstamps - a good friend on Twitter and one of our circle of friends. Now the whole thing really came crashing down. Whilst Mike was enjoying the free hospitality of another friend, he'd carelessly left his passport lying around. His name wasn't Mike Paterson - it was in fact Michael Gordon Bracci. A couple of photocopies were taken, just in case. Why would he be lying about his name to us all? Mark had asked an official contact to do some checks. Mark had been doing a lot of work building up a dossier without any of us knowing. No one with those names had any form of House of Commons clearance.
Religious Right Alert
It doesn't take much to do some Internet searches. Michael Gordon Bracci is the real name of another alias Credo has used: Mike Daley. He appears on the "Religious Right Alert" website as a "notorious and self-pronounced 'shit disturber' on the Canadian Anglican Right". He seems to be some relatively low-level character who sets up cyber squats and was pushing for the schism of the Anglican Church in North America over gay and women's rights through a body called the "Cranmer Foundation" (of which he was the sole director). He moved to London in 2009 and suffers from MS.
Mike is still married. His wife is not a dead medical doctor in Sydney, but in fact teaches philosophy at an American university. She is a former evangelical Christian, turned traditionalist. From what I can see on line she appears to be very much alive. She did grow up in the Black Forest, which he had mentioned a couple of times to me about his "late wife". She talks in one Canadian magazine interview about their traditional marriage and how her husband Mike has moved to London for a job in PR, but that they make things work. I've no idea if she knows about his now girlfriend and how that fits in exactly with this viewpoint.
Conclusions
Well, Credo is a fake. He's a confidence trickster, he's pulled the wool over the eyes of many people and he's been left to do it by the actual Downing Street communications team. Did no one there think to check out and stop someone so well known on Twitter in political circles, who claimed to be so high level? Instead MPs were happily chatting to him in public.
He's taken hospitality and money from friends of mine. According to his passport he has no residency or work permit to be in this country. He has weaseled his way in to a group of people - including gays and lesbians - even though he is a traditionalist Christian and has worked to further Church homophobia. He has spoken positively about people I know from the Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement - but whom he must actually know from the bitter "other side of the fence".
He's currently - apparently - back in Canada, where his mother died unexpectedly just a few hours after his arrival. His response to the hundreds of messages of sympathy and all the attention on Twitter was "wow, thanks everybody." Michael Gordon Bracci been building up a totally false identity for himself and thriving off the attention he's been getting. His motivation? Well in his own words "I struggle with self-esteem and depression and invent elaborate fantasies to cope with the depression and anxiety" [sent to me by IM by him at 16.49 after this was originally posted].
How do I feel? Angry, sick, embarrassed, violated, and furious on behalf of my friends he has exploited. Police and Immigration should be involved here. If I find out Mike has set his foot in this country again, they will be.
![]() |
| Pic c/o @Art_Li - the irony of Credo's name is not lost on me |
For anyone thinking "whatever" I want to stress this is not about a fake Twitter account - it's about a person who has used the medium to trick people in real life and caused massive upset. Help he clearly needs, but my responsibility is to those I care about, which is why I published this.
21/8 Finally, according to his girfriend (and as tweeted by her) his mother is "very much alive" and she has spoken to her. She has also tweeted that Michael conned her personally out of £15,000.


"So those of us who knew him started talking to one another. It's not easy if you're wrong to be going out there and doubting every thing about a friend, to your mutual friends."
ReplyDeleteI do soooo sympathise - you start by worrying that you are the only one to have doubts - go through the period of having everyone land on your head for having doubted this eminent person - and, relax, eventually the truth outs and you are congratulated for having unmasked them as the very ordinary con artist that they are.....!
We should be surprised that politics attracts fat fraudulent fantasists? Really?
http://www.annaraccoon.com/politics/libertarian-liberties/
Outstanding detective work!
ReplyDeleteI am sorry to read of all this Peter. You are a good person and I have had the privilege of meeting you and enjoying your company.
ReplyDeleteYou give a lot of yourself on Twitter and on your blog; this has earned you many friends as well as winning you the trust and admiration of literally hundreds of people, including journalists, politicians and other prominent figures. I see daily how many people hang on your every word.
Sadly, there are some using the internet who will abuse people's trust, even yours and your followers'. In this respect, Twitter is no different to any chat room, message board or online dating site.
There are a lot of victims of Credo's fakery, and a lot of real life time, emotion and hospitality has been wasted. I don't know what else to say, other than we all need to be more precautious. Maybe there are some who need to pinch themselves and think twice about their emotional involvement in social networking sites.
I can understand just how you feel Peter...only too well but you have been taken in by a man who has taken us all in. As the alarm bells rang you didnt just shunt them to one side....you acted on them and you found the truth...
ReplyDeleteDon't feel too bitter about this...a friendship betrayed is always going to hurt...but in the end you are still you...a man we have all come to love and trust.
I hope you haven't lost money...if you have go to the police...
JUst knowing you have had this man in your home accepting your hospitality is bad enough...but if anything criminal has occurred then you should get it sorted or it will only eat at you..
You've been brave, posted a great blog...alerted us all to whats happened .
Well done.. I would hug you if you were closer.
A staggering story of fake identity and how easy it is to dupe people online. Here's another I found recently worth a read (not related to politics and not safe for work, probably)
ReplyDeletehttp://xiaxue.blogspot.com/2011/03/peter-coffin-is-loser.html
I don't mean this to be a hostile comment Peter, but I'm surprised by all of this.
ReplyDeleteI have a bit of a rule around social networking - generally to only befriend someone on Facebook that I've actually met a few times (except one or two exceptions of people who I've known by reputation for a long time) and I tend to treat people I meet via Twitter with absolute scepticism - I almost work on the assumption that - on Twitter - every identity is an avatar.
In terms of confidence or disclosure, I'd need a great deal more by way of testimonial from others that I know.
I tend to the view that people are entitled to a fantastic alter-ego if they want one (I don't) and the way to deal with it is to separate what they say from who they are.
I've noticed a lot of people on social media taking each other a great deal more seriously than they should, and from your account, unless there's something hefty missing, I suspect that not everyone would have been duped like this.
This has implications all over the shop, from the libel courts, through criminal law (the whole Twitter Joke Trial was a classic example of prosecutors not knowing what social media was and what people are when they're using it) and into cases like the one you've outlined here.
I say all of this aware of the view that 'being trusting' is usually a virtue. I'm just surprised at many people's lack of scepticism about each others' claims about themselves.
Credo often pops into my timeline, or did. I assume he will be very quiet now, at least under the Credo soubriquet. I fear he has found a formula that works well for a while so I have no doubt he will pop up again. My point is that while he often popped up in my timeline, I did not press the 'follow' button. It always seemed suspect to me. Perhaps the lesson is more not about conmen, because they will never go away, but to keep online and real lives separate just a tiny bit more.
ReplyDeleteI noticed I was unable to find any trace of Credo's supposed departure from No. 10, save for his own claims.
ReplyDeleteAlso on several occasions, that voice we all hear, and all usually ignore, piped-up squeaking something about Personality Disorders of the Narcissistic/Borderline type.
Having said that, the most disconcerting aspect of his behaviour is that he didn't seem to be a c-nt like the rest of his Tory chums.
Sadly this is all too common. My cousin does exactly this sort of thing on twitter/facebook/various forums etc and has done for years. She has a large circle of on-line friends who never seem to question her claims - despite the fact that nothing ever marries with her previous claims - jobs/education etc. All make believe. Now I never believe ANYTHING I read.
ReplyDeleteSo, you (like your cronies) have such an inflated view of your own self importance that you think that a high level prime ministerial advisor wants to spend time with you and even graces your friend's homes by allowing them to accomodate him.
ReplyDeleteYou and the hangers on that you hang around with believed this man because you wanted to. Do tell the police and give them as good a laugh as you have given me.
Bill, although you may only have friends on your own "level" many of us do know people in whizz-bang jobs. Twitter does bring odd friendships together, especially given most of us are political junkies.
ReplyDeleteHaving met Credo I'm upset, the guy seemed really really friendly and a very good sport. This is all very sad.
A most interesting tale - yet another reminder that nothing on the internet is certain.
ReplyDeleteAnd just who are you "Pete"? Your Blogger profile certainly give no clue.
To be clear, I still have no idea who you are, "Pete", far less who "Lord Credo", whoever he is, may be in reality. My own identity, for what it is worth, is pretty easily-traceable if you know where to look. You, on the other hand "Pete", well that is quite another matter.
I still have the photos of you and the Bavarian goat, don't forget that.
ReplyDeletePerhaps somewhat inappropriate but Lord Credo appears to be back.
ReplyDelete'Credo' once claimed that he could get something to David Cameron's office for me. I said I would not trust him with it unless he could guarantee delivery. That's when he starting getting hostile then broke off, accusing me of being a fantasist.
ReplyDeleteNot that surprising. Google 'Craig Colclough' - he's been on Twitter in various guises.
ReplyDeleteI'm appalled by his actions. I can't comprehend how people find it in themselves to trespass so shockingly on the hospitality and sympathies of others. I really feel for you. I never personally had much contact with him, and I'm very glad of that now. But so many on Twitter did. It sickens me.
ReplyDeleteA "Mike Paterson" was an occasional commenter at Guido and with an ID that links (implausibly, given the style of comments) to another Mike Paterson.
ReplyDeletePeter
ReplyDeleteI can't imagine the hurt and anger you and your friends must feel because of this conman's behaviour. There is nothing new about confidence tricks, they have been around forever, but the Internet does allow people to be what they want to Be. It seems implausible that your group of friends are the only people to have been conned by him.
Peter, you have wonderful values are a good and genuine man I hope you will not allow this conman to affect the way you intereact online.
Best wishes
Alan
If clever people are so gullible maybe I should give up the day job and become a Twitter fake.
ReplyDeleteReally very sorry to hear how you have been affected so personally throughout all of this, and to all those that have.
ReplyDeleteWell done for exposing him though, and this was a fascinating read.
Sympathy.
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking that this is more a story about a traditional con-man than it is about Twitter anonymity, which is what some people may try and make it.
PS I trust that someone has made the police aware and requested an investigation.
ReplyDeleteNever trust a man who wears cufflinks
ReplyDeletePS. I wear cufflinks
I can never find my cufflinks - must be trustworthy!
ReplyDeleteExcellent work on exposing this web of lies and deceit Peter.
ReplyDeleteThose posting comments either gloating or criticising you make no sense to me. I imagine they're the sort that like to rubberneck at road accidents too, or pop up with the "told you so" as soon as they get a whiff of problems.
I assume that the people who are saying that Peter et al are gullible, have never met anyone from Twitter they've become friends with, never met a friend of a friend they've become friends with and go through life with a con-man radar ensuring they are never so stupid as to take someone at face value.
ReplyDeleteTrusting someone you like isn't gullible it's human nature. It's very sad that there are people willing to take advantage of good nature and frankly even more sad that there are people on the sidelines being smug.
What Bear Faced Lady said.
ReplyDeleteWhat bear faced lady said.
ReplyDeleteI have met a lot of people through blogs and twitter, including Credo and Peter. The vast majority are nice people. I don't decide if I want to be friends with them based on twitter, I decide that after I've met them face to face. Some are just like their on line personas, some are very different. Clearly it is sensible to be wary at first, in case the real life person is not someone you should be spending time with, despite having a good on line rapport.
Credo's duplicity happened off-line as he built relationships with people in the real world. This is not a story about conning people over twitter. This is about conning people who are your friends and aquaintences in real life.
What Fat Jacques said.
ReplyDeleteI've had the misfortune to meet two or three compulsive liars in my life, and sadly this tale is all too familiar. There is never just one extravagant claim, there are always two or three (in other words, it's not enough to claim you're Fay Wray's niece, you must also be a status Cherokee and the illegitimate daughter of the Duke of Bedford and that you will inherit the estate - even though DeBrett's clearly indicates it's entailed). I've tried confronting some of these people and got precisely nowhere. I gather for one's own sanity it's best to just play along and try to find it funny, something I find it difficult to do.
ReplyDeleteI still prefer to be someone who trusts people until they've given me a reason to distrust them rather than mistrustful until someone has proven they're worthy of trust. But tales like this make me wonder if I've made the right decision.
Phew! Amazing....
ReplyDeleteSadly there's a lot of these fantasists about. One I know of in the Cotswolds preys on women by pretending to be retired military & spining a sob story about a head injury. They steal people's lives because their own is so inadequate.
ReplyDeleteSorry Bear Faced Lady. It's really not as simple as that. You seem to have a one-way street of misanthropy where only people who trust everyone almost unconditionally pass the test.
ReplyDeleteI'm happy to permit fantasists into my life - as long as we both know what the score is. But you *do* need ways of knowing....
Having read your insightful post and following our brief exchange on Twitter, I commend you on your well-reasoned, responsible and balanced reporting. Whether Credo a.k.a. Michael Daley, a.k.a. Michael Gordon Bracci, a.k.a. Michael Paterson will resurface on Twitter or the blogosphere remain to be seen.
ReplyDeleteFollowing my invitation to Credo to confirm or deny the allegations made against him, he sent me the following DM:
"I won't run away from this and will make it right by my friends. I'm mentally ill and have been for some time. May take......you up on your offer."
Direct message sent by Lord Credo (@Lord_Credo) to you (@AntoninPribetic) on Aug 20, 1:06 PM.
The offer refers to an invite to write a guest blog post, which remains open.
This sounds very like a confidence trickster who conned my family when I was younger, even to the point of being Canadian (or calling himself Canadian at least!) He even looks very similar, though it is hard to tell with the sunglasses, his hair and facial features are certainly similar. This was in Nottingham though, more than 10 years ago.
ReplyDeleteHe called himself Spicheck Gwardinski and/or Lee Hayes at the time. I still don't know what the truth was, and what were lies. It's a weird and scary experience though, and I feel sorry that many other people have had to go through the same thing.
Just now, I've been able to trace a company he started called Infinity Bytes Technologies UK back from Nottingham to a previous address in Cardiff. It makes me wonder if this really is the same guy...
Great post and salutory tale.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing it.
(BTW - I came to you via TradingAsWDR - who I know really does exist.)
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete